5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021

This post was most recently updated on June 26th, 2021

There are many things on the homestead that you can use a dehydrator for. Before I owned a dehydrator, I used to use the oven for anything that I needed to dry out, but an oven really isn’t the same as a dehydrator. I have decided to review the 5 best dehydrators.

Please read: This information is provided for educational purposes only and is not intended to treat, diagnose or prevent any disease. We encourage you to make your own health care decisions in partnership with a qualified health care professional.

This post contains affiliate links, this means at no extra cost to you, we make a commission from sales. Please read our Disclosure Statement

The difference between drying in an oven and using a dehydrator

Ovens generally have a higher minimum temperature than what you want to dehydrate food at for optimal quality.

If you are like me and you own an older oven without a fan forced option, they are even worse as the food will definitely cook before they dry.

To dry food properly you need to keep the temperature as low as required, a fan to blow off the moisture, and plenty of ventilation to let the moisture out.

While you CAN manage this in an oven (sort of) you will get a much more consistent and better product if you have a properly designed dehydrator.

RELATED: Making fruit leather

RELATED: Making jerky at home

RELATED: Dehydrating without a dehydrator

My Favorite Dehydrator

Of the 5 dehydrators that I reviewed,  for the price, functionality and size I would recommend this dehydrator  – if you live in NZ this is the same one under a NZ label.

I dream of having one of the larger, more sturdy stainless steel dehydrators, but for all the things we dehydrate, the one we have works just fine for our needs.

I dry vegetables, fruit leather and jerky overnight using the auto timer cut off and have used it to dry herbs and mushrooms with great success too.

What to look for when choosing a dehydrator

The choice of dehydrator models is vast, and so are the specs and the resulting price range. What do you look for in a dehydrator, and how do you decide which is best for you?

I have used a fair share of dehydrators over the years, and I can tell you, if you plan on using one regularly, it is worth getting one that will do what you need easily and well.

Does the size of the dehydrator matter?

The smaller, cheaper dehydrators are great if you occasionally have something to dry and they work particularly well with small batches of herbs or plants. If you are planning on drying your entire tomato harvest, use your dehydrator to make yogurt or other ferments or plan on making lots of fruit leather, you will be much better off getting one of the larger square shaped ones.

Metal trays or plastic trays in a dehydrator? Does it matter?

Most of the cheaper machines come with plastic trays which while they can be washed in the dishwasher, they will become brittle and break over time. Metal trays will last much longer and are not as likely to warp or buckle. Some of the more expensive ones will also come with fruit leather trays that are solid.

Top loading or front loading dehydrators?

Dehydrators that load from the top down are much more fiddly to load with liquids, and you are more likely to up-end your trays and drop stuff inside once it is dry. Ones that open at the front that have sliding trays are much easier to check on, and remove, add or rotate trays as required without unstacking the whole machine.

Wattage in dehydrators

The higher the wattage, the more power the machine will be using while it is on, however, the higher wattage machines will also dry more food and faster than the lower wattage machines.

Temperature adjustments

Different foods will dehydrate best at different temperatures, so it is best to choose a machine that has an adjustable temperature option.

Built in timers

Most foods will need to dehydrate for many many hours, and if you are like us, your power is cheaper overnight. So with a dehydrator with a timer built in, you can set it and forget it, knowing that it will turn itself off when it is done, which allows you to make use of the cheaper power at night, or to get some drying done while you are out of the house.

Fan position

A fan in the top or the bottom of the unit will have a less even drying effect than one that is in the back of the unit. For smaller batches this will be less of an issue, but if you are doing lots of drying, all the tray rotations will become annoying.

Best Entry Level Dehydrator

NESCO FD-75A, Snackmaster Pro Food Dehydrator

Perfect for preparing backpacking foods

★★★ 3/5 stars

5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image

 
Specs:

  • Adjustable thermostat allows you to dry different foods at proper temperatures (95º-160º F)
  • Powerful top-mounted 2100 RPM fan
  • 600 Watts of drying power.
  • Comes with 5 trays, but is expandable to 12 trays. (Trays are 13 1/2″ in diameter)
  • Made in the USA of Global and Domestic parts
  • A 52-page recipe and instruction book is also included.

Pros:

Very affordable
Fits in a lot of trays for a small machine
Good reviews
BPA free

Cons:

The plastic trays are a little flimsy
No timer

You can get it here (if you are in NZ this SUNBEAM is very similar)

Best Dehydrator for Jerky

Homdox Food and Fruit Dehydrator

Perfect for small time jerky makers or when you have a little produce to dry at once.

★★★★ 4/5 stars

 5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image

Specs:

  • Variable tray stacking system allows you to stack the trays at two different heights to accommodate foods of varying sizes and thicknesses.
  • Large 8-tier design with 2lb/1kg food capacity per tray allows you to preserve different types of food simultaneously, thanks to a digital thermostat
  • Adjustable between 95-160F (35 – 70°C)
  • 400 watts of drying power

Pros:

Mid-sized capacity
Variable heat
Timer
Can put trays in dishwasher
Quiet operation

Cons:

No recipe book or instructions
Trays are plastic

You can get it here  (if you are in NZ this one is similar)

Best Dehydrator for Fruits and Vegetables

Ivation 6 Tray Digital Electric Food Dehydrator

Great for fruits, fruit-rolls, vegetables, herbs, and meats. This is the dehydrator I have and LOVE.

★★★★ 4.5/5 stars

5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image

Specs:

• 6 removable, height adjustable racks (13″x12″)
• Digital thermostat adjusts from 95 F to 158 F
• Digital timer with automatic shutoff
• Includes 1 solid and 1 mesh sheet
• Drip tray collects any residue from drying process
• Rear-mounted fan for even drying
• Overheating safety protection
• Complies with US electrical safety regulations ETL
• Comprised of BPA Free materials
• Dimensions: 17.71 x 13.58 x 12.40 inch
• Rated power: 480w

Pros:

Easy to use
Variable heat
Timer with auto shut off
Holds a lot of food
Comes with clear instructions

Cons:

Can smell a bit when first used
Temperature increments are in 9F lots (5C)

You can get it here  (If you are in NZ this Sunbeam is the same, and it is the one I have)

Best Dehydrator for Bigger Families

Magic Mill Commercial pro

Perfect for when you have lots of food to process at once

★★★★ 4.5/5 stars

5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image

Specs:

  • Automatic shut off when timer is done 
  • Transparent door allows you to easy monitor progress 
  • Large capacity with 10 trays you can have more than 13 lbs of food dehydrating at once 
  • Overheating safety protection 
  • Drip tray collects any residue from drying process
  • Temperature Range: 95°F to 167°F (with 9 degree increments)
  • Wattage: 1000 watts
  • Warranty: 1-year Limited

Includes 
☑ 10 Stainless steel height adjustable racks
☑ 10 fine mesh sheet 
☑ 5 nonstick Fruit Leather sheets 
☑ 1 set oven mitts 

Pros:

Large
Well made stainless steel body
Stainless steel trays
VERY quiet
Dries evenly/no rotation needed
Timer and auto shut off

Cons:

We couldn’t find any!

You can get it here (if you are in NZ this one is similar)

Best Dehydrator for EVERYTHING

Excalibur 3926TCDB 9-Tray

The Excalibur is the premium option when you are looking at dehydrators! It is the dehydrator homesteaders dream of.

★★★★★ 5/5 stars

5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image5 Best Dehydrators for a Homestead: A review for 2021 promo image

Specs:

  • 9-Tray dehydrator with 15 square feet of drying space
  • Includes a flexible poly-screen tray insert to prevent foods from sticking and trays do not need to be moved or rotated during operation
  • Adjustable thermostat and 26-hour timer
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • Made in USA
  • 600 watts
  • Includes Guide to Dehydration and Preserve It Naturally

Pros:

Made of stainless steel
Stainless steel mesh trays
Can be used to: dehydrate fruits, vegetables, nuts, meat for jerky, fruit puree for fruit roll-ups, raise bread or make homemade yogurt
Super fast – jerky can be done in only 4 hours
Very easy to clean up

Cons:

It isn’t cheap! But then with a 10 year warranty it is probably worth it!

You can get it here (or if you are in NZ you can get one here)

How to choose the best dehydrator for the homestead

 

 

Do you need more delicious goodness fresh from the farm?

 

Sign up for our weekly Fresh From the Farm Newsletter

All goodness, no spam.

Get exclusive content, discounts and updates.

Invalid email address
We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.